Sunday, August 20, 2006

Rick Pearson: A good reporter writes a bad column

Crossposted on Marathon Pundit.

Rick Pearson has been writing about Illinois politics for at least a decade, and he's generally considered to be a fair and decent reporter. I'm a little biased, as in 2002, I submitted a question to Pearson that not only got me invited into the studio audience of the final gubernatorial debate between eventual victor
Democrat Rod Blagojevich and Republican Jim Ryan, but he used my question too.

"Blago" is running for re-election this year, he's being challenged by feisty Republican Judy Baar Topinka.

Today Pearson unloaded a stink bomb in the Chicago Tribune. In his column, Rick wrote about the 34 city tour that the Republican party statewide ticket kicked off last week in Springfield. The tour will focus on that forgotten "corner" of the state: that part of Illinois south of Interstate 80, better known as "Downstate."

Up until about 10 years ago, heavily Democratic Cook County was counterbalanced by the Republican suburbs and Republican Downstate. The latter two aren't as "Red" as they used to be, and Illinois is now a "deep blue" state.

So focusing on Downstate makes a lot of sense for the GOP here.

Rick Pearson isn't so sure, as he wrote today. Free registration required:

Topinka said Blagojevich's treatment of the Downstate region was "rather shabby" and said her tour, which winds up Thursday in DuPage County, was meant to "go back out there and say, `Look, you count.'"

"There is something more than just the city of Chicago and Cook County," said Topinka, who lives in Riverside. "These are very important--God knows I love them dearly--but you know, it's like a mother with many children, you love all of them, and you have to bring everybody in."

Still, Illinois' political history is littered with candidates who stumbled while trying to strike the right symbolic note in their appeal to Downstate voters.

Topinka chose to launch her bus tour at the historic train depot where Abraham Lincoln delivered his farewell to Springfield en route to assuming the presidency. And we all know how Lincoln returned to Springfield.

Huh? What the heck is that supposed to mean? I'm sure Pearson didn't mean that Judy will return to Springfield as a hero, as Lincoln did.

New Ruberry posting rule: Anonymous comments, the "other anonymous" excepted, will be deleted. See my most recent Wal-Mart post below for a detailed explanation for my decision. Also, keep in mind, the sister blog to this one has a checkered history in regards to anonymous posters.

16 comments:

John Ruberry 10:56 AM  

I'm sure Rick is reading this now and thanking God for this invaluable insight

Buh bye!

Levois 11:06 AM  

A hero. I was thinking dead. And that would have been such a huge leap.

Anonymous,  11:24 AM  

Aw, someone has thin skin...Rick at least believes in the first amendment.

grand old partisan 12:29 PM  

This isn’t even my fight, but I just have to jump in….

Anon 11:24, you’re an idiot.

If John’s removal of the first anonymous post was prompted by “think skin,” why would he reprint the insult himself?

Last time I checked, Pearson doesn’t write a blog. Any assumption as to what he would do regarding anonymous posts is purely that, an assumption. Now, you can, of course, write a letter to the editor of the Tribune responding to Pearson’s articles, but if you don’t sign your name to it, it will certainly not be published. Would that be an infringement of your first amendment rights?

Anonymous,  12:52 PM  

You're right, it's not your fight, so mind your own business...moron.

grand old partisan 1:00 PM  

Interesting, I don't really see how your criticism of John is any less my business than John's criticism of Pearon is yours. How dare you try to insult and intimidate me for exercising my 1st amendment rights!

Yellow Dog Democrat 1:45 PM  

John, it wasn't a bad line, unless you consider it distasteful to acknowledge that Lincoln was assassinated.

An of course, his train ride back from Washington, D.C. to Springfield was historic. People lining the tracks across what was then pretty much the entire country to pay their respects.

I was hoping for a little more insight about candidates that have stumbled trying to use downstate as a cornerstone in a statewide general election.

Poshard is the most obvious. Salvi v. Durbin.

Other than that, most did pretty well. Simon. Edgar. Fitzgerald.

Abraham Lincoln 2:36 PM  

JBT is definately more Mary Todd than myself.

John Ruberry 3:23 PM  

Time for some more...deletions

enviro zealot 3:47 PM  

John,

The identity section for comments on Illinoize allows for an "Anonymous" username. None of the other featured bloggers are deleting such posts. As long as the comments meet the posting guidelines (e.g., no profanity or vulgarity), they should be allowed. What you are doing amounts to censorship.

Anonymous,  4:11 PM  

Hi, my name is John...I don't like people who make fun of my posts, so I'm going to delete them.

Pawl Pry 4:51 PM  

As near as I can tell, almost every blog I have seen eventually ends up having to post the following-
"This is not a publicly owned forum. Someone owns & operates this blog and gets to set the rules. Deleting a post is entirely up to the administrator... if you don't like the rules, start your own blog with your own rules."

enviro zealot 10:10 PM  

pawl pry, who is the blog administrator for Illinoize, John or Rich Miller? John is listed as a featured blogger, not administrator. Moreover, where does it say in the posting guidelines for this blog that anonymous posts are not acceptable? As far as I can tell, John is the only blogger with a policy of deleting anonymous posts.

I have no problem if John wants to delete an offensive post, but he should be able to tolerate anonymous posts that may be critical by either responding or ignoring, as he wishes.

John Ruberry 10:22 PM  

Read the below Wal-Mart post. Rich told me since it's my post, I can do what I want. Now, if I was really a jerk, I could have ppl go to my site, drive up traffic, and "approve" comments, such as one Illinoize blogger does.

Speaking of Rich, didn't he catch a bunch of "anonymous" commenters from Springfield knocking Topinka.

It's crap like this I'm talking about:

Hi, my name is John...I don't like people who make fun of my posts, so I'm going to delete them.

Grow up or start your own blog.

Anonymous,  7:44 AM  

I didn't realize this was your blog John...finally, some news here.

Anonymous,  3:23 PM  

John Ruberry: A bad blogger writes a bad blog.

CTA Bus Status

WMAQ Chicago NBC 5 Video News Feed

There was an error in this gadget

  © Blogger template The Professional Template by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP